LendingClub Returns: LendingClub View

Buried deep in the LendingClub financial statements is a curious number. 7.2% is the investment return LendingClub believes their loans should earn for their investors. The 2016 return estimate, the weighted average across all loan grades, is down from 9.0% reported for 2015, presumably due to greater projected losses. It is consistent with the investment returns reported by other asset classes.

This is from the most recent 10-k filing: (p.107)

Investment returns are hard to come by. They are either highly proprietary, expensive to calculate or non-existent as investors are often sold a “story” rather than data. Definitive investment returns can only come from calculations for a group of loans, aka vintages, that completed all scheduled and expected payments. For example, investment return on 36-month loans originated in Q3 2017 won’t be known until Q4 2020.

Alternative measure of returns relies on valuing a portfolio of loans, while in repayment, at the end of each investment reporting period. These are outstanding obligations, valued based on repayment and investment return expectations. This approach is circular since valuation requires estimating investment rate of return to measure investment rate of return.

Valuations of illiquid financial instruments are inherently subjective. Yet, this is the only method of tracking investment performance in existence. Our earlier post illustrates that despite the subjectivity, portfolio valuations can produce highly reliable numbers.

In May 2017, Prosper corrected its investment return calculations. The returns dropped about 2%. The company called it a “glitch.” Note that Prosper provides current yields rather than the actual all-in investment returns. Current yield is calculated by dividing coupon payments by the principal amount outstanding. It ignores changes in the principal balance itself, which makes it vastly inferior to the true investment rate of return measure.

Below are some more examples where lenders disclose their own rate of return estimates:

 Lender Return Return Range
 LendingClub 7.2% 1.2% – 16.6%
 Prosper 7.3% 4.0% – 15.9%
 EZCORP na 9.0% – 22.0%

Correlation between asset classes can be as important as the rates of return themselves. The correlation between marketplace lending credits and traditional asset classes is broadly assumed to be low, making marketplace lending desirable from the portfolio theory perspective. However, correlation cannot be measured without reliable investment return numbers, thus the true correlation is not really known at this point. Once tech-enabled marketplace lenders build robust investment reporting systems, this growing asset class will become even more desirable as a fixed income investment than it is today.

Schedule a free consultation with us by CLICKING HERE.

More Updates

Technology Valuation: US GAAP View

It is hard to underestimate the importance of technology in modern enterprises.  From legacy manufacturing to artificial intelligence and life science breakthroughs, technology plays an ever-increasing role.  However, the need to assign a specific value to it may arise only when the enterprise is faced with a strategic transition.  A merger or an acquisition is one such event.

Your Valuation Needs Income Approach

The value of any business is defined by the amount of future cash flows it can generate.  The three basic valuation methods are the income approach, the market approach, and the cost approach.   Only the income approach directly addresses the question of value.  It is the first on the list of recommended methods in all guideline literature.  In fact, the

Intellectual Property, Goodwill, and Other Intangible Assets

The predominant amount of S&P 500 value comes from intangible assets and goodwill (“Intangibles”) of the underlying companies. It is no surprise that patents and brands are more valuable than desks. Understanding the components of intangible value is of great relevance to tax authorities and financial stakeholders.

Schedule a Call

Most new projects will require a brief introductory conversation. Unless you are a returning client asking for an update to a old valuation, please use the calendar below to schedule a call with us:

Send a Message

We are located in the San Francisco Bay Area, while our clients cover much broader geography, from Southern California to the East Coast and Europe. Please contact us with questions and inquiries. Also, feel free to stop by on your way to the beautiful Sonoma or Napa Valley.

Schedule a Call