Blog

Intellectual Property, Goodwill, and Other Intangible Assets


The predominant amount of S&P 500 value comes from intangible assets and goodwill (“Intangibles”) of the underlying companies. It is no surprise that patents and brands are more valuable than desks. Understanding the components of intangible value is of great relevance to tax authorities and financial stakeholders.

Intangibles can be broken down into three categories: intellectual property (IP), relationship-based assets, and goodwill. Let’s talk about each.

Intellectual Property

Intellectual property, as a term, needs clarification. It is not uncommon to think about IP as something that one can’t touch. Either knowledge or intelligence or both, it may seem as a metaphysical entity. As a result, IP terminology is often misused.

A quick google definition of IP is:

a work or invention that is the result of creativity, such as a manuscript or a design, to which one has rights and for which one may apply for a patent, copyright, trademark, etc.

IP assets are concrete beings. In fact, you can see them, touch them, classify them, sell them, steal them, transport them, and so on. We know that Google is great because it has great software, Pfizer because it has great patents, and Disney because it has great copyright content. Coca-Cola may sell a recipe but retain a trade name.

Simply asking for an “IP valuation” is not sufficient to understand what needs to be done. The request does exclude other intangibles, such as relationship-based assets and goodwill. In the context of a business acquisition, “IP valuations” may not cover the entire scope of work required.

IP valuations can be performed using income-based, cost-based, and sometimes market-based approaches. The income-based approach relies on financial projections attributable to a specific IP asset or a group of assets; it is the most theoretically sound method whilst most difficult to implement. The cost-based approach equates IP value to the cost of developing the asset; it has the potential to be rather accurate. The market-based approach is not common, though does have its place in certain situations.

Relationship-Based Assets

The IP covers assets that are proprietary by nature (one can have a title to it); they are easier to separate from the business entity physically. Relationship-based assets are closely associated with business operations. They may dissipate quickly without the support of the product or service. Relationship-based assets include customer relationships, backlog, servicing contracts, and non-compete agreements.

The value of the relationship-based assets can also be measured quantitatively. Supported by specific contractual terms, historical customer behavior, and observable financial performance, such assets are often valued with greater confidence than their IP cousins.

Goodwill

Goodwill represents the residual value of the company after attributions are made to all tangible assets as well as IP-based and relationship-based assets (a.k.a. identifiable intangible assets). Goodwill represents future technology, future customers, business processes, and infrastructure that unites individual assets in a greater value-producing organization.

To value goodwill, one will have to value the entire business and subtract the values of the individual identifiable intangible and tangible assets. We don’t believe any effort should be put into the income approach style of goodwill valuation.

Valuation Requirements

IP valuation is required in both tax compliance and financial reporting. It is often valued for strategic and litigation purposes as well. In transfer pricing (IRC Sec. 482), IP valuations are necessary to establish asset values in transactions between related parties.

Purchase price allocations (PPA) is another valuation study where all identifiable intangible assets and goodwill values are determined. PPAs are performed when the entire entity is acquired. IRC Sec. 1060 and FASB Accounting Standard Codification Topic 805 govern PPAs. Each provides its own classifications of intangible assets.

Conclusion

The first step in any valuation study is to define the property being valued. The property to be valued is determined by tax, legal, or accounting considerations. In PPA, a valuation specialist will assist in determining which discrete intangible assets must be valued. However, it is up to the client to determine if the PPA is needed (i.e., the entire entity changed hands) or if an individual and specific IP asset (or a group of assets) have to be valued.

More Updates

Secondary Transactions and Valuations

Stock pickers believe they can value assets better than the market. The research shows otherwise. The financial accounting rules don’t play around and require observable transaction values to be the primary indicators. This topic is relevant for most privately held security valuations, including broad fair value issues, IRC 409A valuations, portfolio valuations, and tax.

Navigating SAFE Valuations

Neither “Safe” nor “Simple,” these Simple Agreements for Future Equity are convertible debt instruments that are often misunderstood and hard to value.

7 Areas to Transform Your Financial Reporting Valuation

Creating shareholder value is the goal of most for-profit entities, where value is viewed in a strictly financial sense.  In the world of startups and VCs, this means maximizing exit valuations. That exit valuation number is of fundamental importance. Exit valuations are built over time. Thus, tracking valuations is critical.  Companies have many opportunities to track their valuations, from upgraded

Schedule a Call

Most new projects will require a brief introductory conversation. Unless you are a returning client asking for an update to a old valuation, please use the calendar below to schedule a call with us:

Send a Message

We are located in the San Francisco Bay Area, while our clients cover much broader geography, from Southern California to the East Coast and Europe. Please contact us with questions and inquiries. Also, feel free to stop by on your way to the beautiful Sonoma or Napa Valley.

Schedule a Call